In Video: Gen Z opposes Trump's immigration tactics on college campuses

Do Non-Citizen Students and Green Card Holders Deserve the Same Due Process Rights as Citizens?

Recent protests by students on student visas and green card holders have sparked controversy and debate over their rights to free speech and due process. Some argue that these individuals, who are in the country temporarily or permanently, do not deserve the same level of protection as U.S. citizens. I share this sentiment, but with a nuanced perspective. While I understand the concerns, I believe that non-citizen students and green card holders should have similar due process rights as citizens, with certain exceptions.

A House is a Home, But a Right to Free Speech Too?

Imagine being invited into someone’s home, and yet you begin to complain about the decor, the food, and the atmosphere. Would you expect the homeowner to allow you to stay indefinitely, even if your criticisms become abusive or disruptive? Probably not. Similarly, when non-citizen students and green card holders exercise their right to free speech on campus or in public spaces, they are not trespassing on someone else’s property; they are engaging in a fundamental human right.

Terrorism and Due Process

The discourse surrounding terrorism and national security has created an atmosphere of fear and mistrust towards non-citizen individuals. However, most cases of alleged terrorist activity involve U.S. citizens, such as those associated with the Proud Boys. This phenomenon highlights the importance of examining the motivations and actions of individuals, regardless of their citizenship status. In general, exercising one’s right to free speech, even if controversial or unpopular, does not constitute a threat to national security.

Misguided Revocation of Visas

Revoking the visas of students who participate in peaceful protests is not a solution. This approach not only violates their right to free speech but also sends a chilling message to others who may wish to engage in similar activities. Deporting individuals who have been involved in campus protests for exercising their right to free speech can have severe consequences for their personal and professional lives. Instead, law enforcement and immigration authorities should focus on addressing any potential security threats separately, without penalizing individuals for exercising their constitutional rights.

Why Due Process Matters

Due process is essential to maintaining a fair and just society. It ensures that individuals are treated equally and that their rights are respected, regardless of their citizenship status. Revocation of visas or deportation without a fair trial or due process can lead to irreparable harm and erode trust in the administration of justice.

A Path Forward

In conclusion, while there may be legitimate concerns about national security and public safety, revoking visas or deporting individuals for exercising their right to free speech is not the solution. Instead, we should focus on addressing the underlying issues and promoting a more inclusive and respectful dialogue. By acknowledging the importance of due process and the right to free speech for all individuals, regardless of their citizenship status, we can build a more just and equitable society.